Tips for Giving Constructive Feedback to Creative Types
As I’ve been posting of late, I’m in the middle of a complete rebrand / redesign. While I do these types of projects on a regular basis with clients, I’m surprised at how fraught with anxiety I’ve been regarding my own redesign.
I realized last week it’s because I’ve had a hard time giving feedback to my designer, Rachel Cunliffe. When working with clients, I see myself as the bridge between them and the designer. My clients don’t speak “design” and “marketing” — it’s up to me to communicate what they want to achieve and then make it happen.
But when it comes to my own work, suddenly, that “bridge” is gone. So when Rachel sent me the first mock up for the interior pages of my site, I didn’t like it. I hemmed and hawed for a few days and fretted. I knew I didn’t want to tell her how to do her job as I didn’t want this result, “How a Web Design Goes Straight to Hell,” cleverly portrayed by The Oatmeal. (This comic always leaves me in stitches because it is the absolute truth. BTDT.)
But I also didn’t want to be a “difficult” client by saying the mock-up wasn’t working for me.
Finally, I sat down and looked at the interior page and the home page she had given me and listed out the differences and why one made me feel “blah” and why the other made my heart sing.
And that made all the difference. Instead of doing her job for her under the guise of “Can you make this and this and this change?” and getting the same result I’ve had for years (safe, boring, ho-hum), I listed out what bothered me about the mock-up and what I liked about the home page — and left it up to her to do her job.
Rachel’s response? “Ahh! Thank you! I see exactly what you mean.” She sent back revised designs and nailed exactly what I was trying to achieve. And, now that we’re on the same page, I’m getting designs for other pages that are knocking my socks off. I just keep looking at them and going WOW!
Tips for giving constructive feedback
When working with creative professionals, it pays to give feedback that helps them “see” what you’re thinking. Design and copywriting are iterative processes — you need communication on both sides to get amazing results. A true professional gracefully welcomes feedback as he/she wants to do a superb job that makes the client look good (as well as meet the project objectives). Consider the following tips:
1. Communicate your ideas — Instead of saying, “That sucks,” or “That’s ugly,” which isn’t helpful, try, “I can see where you’re going with that but what I was really envisioning was this,” and then explain as best you can what you had in mind. Or, do as I did. I explained what I didn’t like and why, but left it up to Rachel to take that feedback and make changes versus telling her what to change.
2. Give high-level concrete feedback — Instead of focusing on micro changes, focus on the overall piece (content, design, etc.). One client I worked with, for example, said to me, “You tend to state things in the negative. Let’s stay positive.” Oh. Thank you. I hadn’t even noticed I was doing that — and once she pointed it out, I made a point to weed it out of my writing.
3. Accept recommendations — I recently had my bathroom redone, right down to the studs. I originally told my plumber and contractor that I wanted a cast iron tub with tile around the shower walls, but they both *highly* recommended I opt for a laminate tub and shower walls due to a number of factors.
I really wanted that cast iron tub but said ok to the laminate and let them do their jobs. The result is a GORGEOUS bathroom. In fact, it’s my dream bathroom. Now when I take a shower, I can’t even imagine why I thought I needed cast iron.
When working with creative pros who know what they’re doing, give them your input, but also listen to their recommendations — and then give them the freedom to achieve superb results for you. We all like to control things, but we hire experts *because* we want different results. When you micro-manage, you cut off creativity, passion and amazing outcomes.
What do you think? Do you have other tips for giving constructive feedback? Post them below.
About the author: Dianna Huff
A B2B web marketing expert, Dianna helps B2B companies grow through SEO, marketing writing, and social media. A frequent speaker, Dianna has been quoted in numerous blogs, books, and articles; her client list includes large and small B2B companies across the U.S. Follow her on Twitter @diannahuff. To receive her e-course on creating great B2B marketing content, subscribe to her e-newsletter, The MarCom Strategist.
















Recent Comments